Sketchup Blog - News and Notes from the Sketchup folks

Like it or not: ratings are back in 3D Warehouse

Today, we’re glad to announce that we’ve implemented a new, cleaner like-based “rating” system for 3D Warehouse.
Fig 1.png

Now, you can "like" models in order to upvote them and store them in your liked models tab
Model courtesy of samothrace41

As you already know, 3D Warehouse is an amazing collection of models of almost anything and everything in the world—from minions to ZZ Top. But sometimes finding the right model can be like searching for a needle in a haystack. User ratings are important signal about a model that lets you know whether other users have vouched for its greatness!

When we re-launched 3D Warehouse earlier this year, there were a few things missing. Perhaps the most commonly asked-about feature, was the old ratings system.

The task of implementing ratings on the new 3D Warehouse gave us the opportunity to re-think the measure of model quality we wanted to capture. Ultimately, when we took a close look at our old 5-star rating system we came to the conclusion that 5 stars was about 4 too many.

When we looked at the data, about 85% of the ratings were either 5-star or 1-star. By and large, people either like a model, or they don’t. This finding wasn’t that surprising since the criteria for 2, 3, and 4-star ratings probably varies from person to person. For your information, with this new like system, we also migrated all of the historical ratings. Any existing ratings that were 3-stars or better were converted into a “Like.”

Another interesting factoid: it turns out that the #1 source of abuse reports from the old Warehouse were from people who filed complaints about their models being rated 1-star. We like the idea of people using ratings to give each other a pat on the back, and acknowledge each other for uploading great stuff. We’re not as fired up about trolls and bullies who cruise around the site and harass others.

We also took into consideration the notion that star rating systems ask a lot from people. After all, your idea of a model that’s deserving of a 4-star rating is probably different than my idea of a 4-star rating. Unfortunately, the subjectivity that goes into the in between ratings often lead to an ambiguous measure of quality.

The new system is simple: you either like something, or not. Your praise for someone else’s work still helps other people find it better, and if a model isn’t to your liking, not up-voting it doesn’t -- and no one’s feelings get hurt.

Even better, liking a model now has an upside for the “liker” as well. When you sign into your 3D Warehouse account and go to your My Warehouse page, you’ll see a new tab for “Liked Models” (see Fig 2) making it easy to get to the models you like time and time again.

Fig 2.png
Fig 2. Keep track of models you like with the Liked Models Tab

You might also notice that a Likes stat has been added to the Model info panel (see Fig 3-1) – and it’s click-able. If you click the Likes link, a panel will slide out from the right side of the screen, containing the list of users who liked that model (see Fig 3-2). You can also see how many models each user has liked and click through to their profile page to see the models listed under their Liked Models tab.

Screen Shot 2014-06-26 at 12.59.00 PM.png
Fig 3. Find the likes stat in the model info panel. Click on “Likes” to find out which users have liked the model.

Lastly, we’ve also added Most Liked as a sort option for search results, so you can now filter your search results for model quality, as measured by the 3D Warehouse community. This is slightly different than the Popularity sort, which is based on download statistics.

We think this new system is a bit easier and maybe even friendlier for everyone, thereby encouraging more liking of more things. Hooray for love; ain’t it grand?

Posted by Mike Tadros, Product Manager

Permalink | Links to this post |
The comments you read here belong only to the person who posted them. We do, however, reserve the right to remove off-topic comments.


TR-JC / 3D-JC said...

Good move, and having just one star (or heart in this case) for a simple "like", is good enough.

Peter said...

I like it.

Matt Kleinmann said...

There needs to be a way to show results from component designers that rise to the top as well. There are a lot of 'bad' (out of scale, over polygonned, and just poorly designed) models from amateur makers. While that's fine, it's frustrating to go through pages and pages of that to find what should be a simple object. Case in point, search "car" or "person". Most of those are unusable.

Matt MacRaild said...

Is it possible to bring back the ability to see the location of the model AND other models around it via map. Previously I could see on a map the location of other models that could be downloaded (via blue or white dots on the map), making creation of context very simple. Now I can only see the location of the model I'm downloading. The deletion of this feature has cause WEEKS worth of additional time to create something that would have previously taken hours!

2001kraft said...

Hello! I would like to say that the idea of seeing who liked your models is quite clever, but I would also like to ask you:
Is it a possibility to add reviews as-well?
Reviews were a great part of the community, now the community is distorted, and the like system hasn't brought much back.
The 3D Warehouse wasn't just a place where we would like or dislike models or just download and upload models to. It was a community where people made new friends, established helpful contacts, and... help each other out with the quality of the model, how to improve it. And it really helped out. I really just want to say that the new like system is great, but it would be even better if reviews would get added!

MJD Universe said...

Can you please add comments/reviews back? The 3D Warehouse really isn't a community anymore if you can't add comments, or at least add enable comments for models you liked. The new rating system is great but it will be much better if you add comments back.